(Announced middle of January)

2021

-

2020

1st team

Brandon Camire - Athlete

Alex Orlando - Punter

2nd team

Jarad Groller - LB

Jamaal Sanders - WR

3rd team

Chad Newhard - DB

Honorable Mention 

Jake Fotta - QB

Tanner Ritter - WR/DB

Justin Roman - OL

2019

1st team

Brandon Camire - RB

2nd Team Defense

Jared Groller - LB

3rd Team Offense

Adam Heiserman - OL(TE)

Honorable Mention

Alex Orlando - K

Jameel Sanders - WR

Jaden Vazquez OL

2018

1st Team

Lubens Myers - RB, DR, KR

Ethan Parvel - QB

2nd Team

Deonte Castro - RB

Izaiah McPherson - DB

3rd Team

Adam Heiserman - DB

Sone Ntoh - RB

Honorable Mention

Dimitri Garcia - OL

Timmy Higgins - LB

Owen Minnix - OL

Jaden Vazquez - OL

2017 

1st Team

Noah Breidinger - LB

2nd Team

3rd Team

Sone Ntoh - RB

Honorable Mention

Joey Barno - DL

Anthony DeCresci - K

Blake Reed - QB

2016 

1st Team

Carson Landis - Kicker

Noah Breidinger - LB

2nd Team

Brian Mantone - DB

3rd Team

Matt Nimas - OL

Josh Artis - WR

Luben Myers - RB

Honorable Mention

Sone Ntoh - RB

Andy Roche - OL

Mike Reeves - OL

Kyle Carraher - DL

Blake Reed - DL